Immoral Truth vs. Untruthful Morals? Attempts to Render Rights and Freedoms Conditional upon Sexual Orientation in Light of Russia's International Obligations
The recently adopted Russian federal legislation provides for imposition of the so-called ‘administrative’ sanctions for dissemination of any information regarding issues related to ‘social equality’ of diverse sexual orientations or gender identities ‘among minors’ for certain purposes (listed in the relevant provision). Under the new laws, such conduct qualifies as an administrative offence. In parallel with the aforementioned amendments, Art. 127 of the Family Code of Russian Federation was modified to prohibit adoptions by married same-sex couples and unmarried citizens of any state where homosexual marriage is permitted.
The present article is written in the attempt to explore whether the recent Russian legislation is compatible with international standards of human rights protection deriving from the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the European Convention on Human Rights and the relevant jurisprudence of international bodies. Is there any possibility to justify the restrictive laws under international law, bearing in mind the support of this legislative trend by the majority of the Russian population?
About the AuthorsMaria Issaeva
Managing Partner at Threefold Legal Advisors LLC (4 Ilyinka, Moscow, 109012, Russia)
Associate at Threefold Legal Advisors LLC (4 Ilyinka, Moscow, 109012, Russia)
1. First LGBT Activists Sentenced under Federal Propaganda Law, Civil Rights Defenders (Dec. 10, 2013), <https://www.civilrightsdefenders.org/news/russia-first-lgbtactivists-sentenced-under-federal-propaganda-law/> (accessed March 5, 2014).
2. Gay Activist Fine with St. Pete Court Verdict, RT (May 4, 2013), <http://on.rt.com/oygzvo> (accessed March 7, 2014).
3. Gay Parades Banned in Moscow for 100 Years, BBC News(Aug. 17, 2012), <http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-19293465> (accessed March 7, 2014).
4. Gay Rights Not Violated in Russia – Putin, RIA Novosti (Apr. 9, 2013), <http://en.ria.ru/russia/20130409/180521813/Gay-Rights-Not-Violated-in-Russia---Putin.html> (accessed March 8, 2014).
5. Human Rights First, Convenient Targets, The Anti-‘Propaganda’ Law & the Threat to LGBT Rights in Russia 8–9 (Aug. 2013), available at <http://www.humanrightsfirst.org/uploads/pdfs/HRF-russias-anti-gay-ban-SG.pdf> (accessed March 7, 2014).
6. ILGA-Europe, Annual Review of the Human Rights Situation of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex People in Europe 187–189 (2013), available at <http://www.ecoi.net/file_upload/90_1369137411_ilga-europe-annual-review-2013.pdf> (accessed March 7, 2014).
7. Itaborahy, Lucas P., & Zhu, Jingshu. State-Sponsored Homophobia World Survey of Laws: Criminalisation, Protection and Recognition of Same-Sex Love 80 (8th ed., ILGA 2013), available at <http://old.ilga.org/Statehomophobia/ILGA_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_2013.pdf> (accessed March 5, 2014).
8. Johnson, Paul. Homosexual Propaganda’ Laws in the Russian Federation: Are They in Violation of the European Convention on Human Rights? (University of York Working Paper [Draft 8th July 2013]), available at <http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=2251005> (accessed March 7, 2014).
9. Joseph, Sarah, & Castan, Melissa. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: Cases, Materials, and Commentary 626 (3rd ed., Oxford University Press 2013).
10. Leontyeva, Anna. Концепция информационной безопасности детей как угроза профессиональной деятельности российских психологов [The Children’s Information Security Framework as a Threat to Professional Activity to Russian Psychologists], Русский журнал [Russian Magazine] (Jan. 8, 2014), <http://www.russ.ru/pole/Koncepciya-informacionnoj-bezopasnosti-detej-kak-ugroza-professionalnoj-deyatel-nosti-rossijskih-psihologov> (accessed March 8, 2014).
11. Magee, James. Freedom of Expression 2 (Greenwood Publishing Group 2002).
12. Morsink, Johannes. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: Origins, Drafting, and Intent (University of Pennsylvania Press 1999).
13. Novoselov, Alexei. За гей-пропаганду впервые наказан ребенок [A Child Was First Time Held Liable for Gay-Propaganda], Znak.com (Febr. 2, 2014) <http://www.znak.com/urfo/news/2014-02-02/1017612.html> (accessed March 8, 2014).
14. Ostrovsky, Yakov. UN and Human Rights (Mezhdunarodnyye otnosheniya 1968).
15. Painter, George. The Sensibilities of Our Forefathers. The History of Sodomy Laws in the United States, <www.glapn.org/sodomylaws/sensibilities/introduction.htm> (accessed March 8, 2014).
16. Report, The Article 19 Law Programme, Traditional Values? Attempts to Censor Sexuality. Homosexual Propaganda Bans, Freedom of Expression and Equality 7 (2013), <http://www.article19.org/data/files/medialibrary/3637/LGBT-propaganda-reportENGLISH.pdf> (accessed March 7, 2014).
17. Ring, Trudy. Russian Church Leader Proposes Criminalizing Homosexuality, Advocate. com (Jan. 10, 2014), <www.advocate.com/news/world-news/2014/01/10/russianchurch-leader-proposes-criminalizing-homosexuality> (accessed March 5, 2014).
18. Vinokurova, Ekaterina. Людей ведь раздражают не геи, а пропаганда: Интервью с Елена Мизулиной, председателем Комитета Государственной Думы по делам семьи, женщин и детей [People are Irritated, Not with Gays, but with Propagand: An Interview with Elena Mizulina, Head of the Duma Committee on Family, Womens and Childrens], Gazeta.ru (June 10, 2013), <http://www.gazeta.ru/politics/2013/06/10_a_5375845.shtml> (accessed March 8, 2014).
19. Zorkin, Valery. Конституционный вектор России. 20 лет реализации Основного закона страны [Russian Constitutional Vector. 20 Years of Implementation of the Basic Law], 2013(6236) Российская газета [Russian Gazette], available at <https://www.academia.edu/5355551/_20_> (accessed March 8, 2014).
20. Концепция информационной безопасности детей [Children’s Information Security Framework] (Roskomnadzor 2013), <http://rkn.gov.ru/mass-communications/p700/p701/> (accessed March 8, 2014).
21. Нарышкин позвал членов ПАСЕ в московские гей-клубы [Naryshkin Invited Members of PACE to Moscow Gay-Clubs], Lenta.ru (Oct. 1, 2013), <http://lenta.ru/news/2013/10/01/naryshkin/> (accessed March 8, 2014).
For citation: Issaeva M., Kiskachi M. Immoral Truth vs. Untruthful Morals? Attempts to Render Rights and Freedoms Conditional upon Sexual Orientation in Light of Russia's International Obligations. Russian Law Journal. 2014;2(1):81-105. https://doi.org/10.17589/2309-8678-2014-2-1-81-105
- There are currently no refbacks.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0.