THE COURT OF JUSTICE OF THE EUROPEAN UNION AND INTERNATIONAL LEGAL ORDER
The author discusses the relationship between two legal orders: international law and European Union (EU) law. The main provisions of this relationship have been established through the precedential practice of the Court of Justice of the European Union – the EU’s main judicial body. This kind of research seems important because of the gap in the theory of international law caused by the immutable dogma of the supremacy of international law. However, modern legal practice demonstrates a certain fragmentation of the international legal order because of the impact of the existence and development of regional supranational legal orders. The EU legal order, with its own special nature (sui generis), is undoubtedly one of the most developed among them. The Court of Justice of the European Union performs a crucial role in the EU legal system concerning application and interpretation of EU law. It provides a uniform interpretation of this law for the purposes of development of supranational integration. In this context the Court of Justice the European Union establishes the status of European law and its relationship with the national legal systems and international law. The Court acts as protector of the EU legal order against the influence of other legal orders. The Court’s precedential practice reveals EU law’s tendency towards its constitutionalization and the development of its autonomy. The latest practice indicates the Court’s powers to review the EU institutions’ acts in relation to the implementation of UN Security Council resolutions. This proves the Court’s ability to establish indirect control even over UN acts.
About the AuthorTETYANA KOMAROVA
Associate Professor, Department of International Law, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University
77 Pushkinskaya St., Kharkiv, 61024, Ukraine
1. Almquist J. A Human Rights Critique of European Judicial Review: Counter-Terrorism Sanctions, 57(2) International and Comparative Law Quarterly 303 (2008).
2. Cannizzaro E. A Machiavellian Moment? The UN Security Council and the Rule of Law, 3(2) International Organizations Law Review 189 (2006).
3. De Burca G. The European Court of Justice and the International Legal Order after Kadi, 51(1) Harvard International Law Journal 1 (2010).
4. De Wet E. The International Constitutional Order, 55(1) International and Comparative Law Quarterly 51 (2006).
5. Eeckhout P. Community Terrorism Listings, Fundamental Rights, and UN Security Council Resolutions: In Search of the Right Fit, 3(2) European Constitutional Law Review 183 (2007).
6. Fassbender B. The United Nations Charter as Constitution of the International Community, 36(3) Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 529 (1998).
7. Hilpold P. EU Law and UN Law in Conflict: The Kadi Case, 13 Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 141 (2009).
8. Kirschner A.J. Security Council Resolution 1904 (2009): A Significant Step in the Evolution of the Al-Qaida and Taliban Sanctions Regime?, 70 Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 585 (2010).
9. Kokott J. & Sobotta C. The Kadi Case – Constitutional Core Values and International Law – Finding the Balance?, 23(4) European Journal of International Law 1015 (2012).
10. Krenn C. Autonomy and Effectiveness as Common Concerns: A Path to ECHR Accession after Opinion 2/13, 16(1) German Law Journal 147 (2015).
11. Kuijper P.J. The Court and the Tribunal of the EC and the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969, 25(1) Legal Issues of European Integration 1 (1998).
12. Lavranos N. Protecting European Law from International Law, 15(2) European Foreign Affairs Review 265 (2010).
13. Rosas A. The Status in EU Law of International Agreements Concluded by EU Member States, 34(5) Fordham International Law Journal 1304 (2011).
14. Scheinin M. Is the ECJ Ruling in Kadi Incompatible with International Law?, 28(1) Yearbook of European Law 637 (2009).
15. Simma B. From Bilateralism to Community Interest in International Law, 250
16. Collected Courses of the Hague Academy of International Law 217 (1994).
17. Tomuschat C. Case Note on Kadi v. Council, 43(2) Common Market Law Review 537 (2005).
18. Tomuschat C. The Kadi Case: What Relationship is there between the Universal Legal Order under the Auspices of the United Nations and the EU Legal Order?, 28(1) Yearbook of European Law 654 (2009).
19. Von Bogdandy A. Constitutionalism in International Law: Comments on a Proposal from Germany, 47(1) Harvard International Law Journal 223 (2006).
For citation: KOMAROVA T. THE COURT OF JUSTICE OF THE EUROPEAN UNION AND INTERNATIONAL LEGAL ORDER. Russian Law Journal. 2017;5(3):140-167. https://doi.org/10.17589/2309-8678-2017-5-3-140-167
- There are currently no refbacks.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0.