The Right to Self-Defence in International Law as a Justification for Crossing Borders: The Turkey-PKK Case within the Borders of Iraq


https://doi.org/10.17589/2309-8678-2016-4-4-62-80

Full Text:


Abstract

International law grants states an inherent right to self-defence. States can exercise this right whenever they face armed attack. However, any country wishing to exercise its right to self-defence must fully consider all the restrictions on this right. The right to self-defence can permit the use of force within the borders of the victim state or on the territory of another state from where the attack is carried out. Accordingly, states may respond to any attack by the armed forces of another state or irregular armed groups that use the territory of other states for their attacks. Turkey is a country with a huge population of Kurdish inhabitants. The Kurds possess distinct origins, history, language, culture and a historical link to their land. Thus, they qualify as a people. For much of their history they have peacefully sought to assert their rights; however, Turkey denied those rights to the extent that the formation of the PKK in 1978 became amove of last resort. When the PKK started demanding Kurdish right to self-determination, Turkey launched military operations against it in self-defence. During the 1980s and 1990s, the PKK established camps in Iraq. On several occasions it withdrew its forces there as part of peace negotiations with the Turkish government. Turkey crossed the Iraqi borders and attacked the camps as part of a state policy to fight the PKK outside its borders. The PKK subsequently handed over the camps to other groups, which never posed any military threat to Turkey, but Turkish forces continued to cross the border into Iraq. This article examines the right of Turkey to use force within the borders of Iraq under the justification of self-defence.

About the Author

Rebaz Khdir
University of Minho-Portugal
Portugal

Ph.D. Student, University of Minho-Portugal, Lecturer, International Law at the University of Raparin in Iraq;

Residencia Universitaria de Santa Tecla, Rua Francisco Machado Owen – Sta Tcla, Braga, 4715-020, Portugal;



References

1. Ahmed M.M.A. Iraqi Kurds and Nation-Building (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012).

2. Alder M.C. The Origin in International Law of the Inherent Right of Self-Defence and Anticipatory Self-Defence, 2 The Western Australian Jurist 107 (2011).

3. Arend A.C. International Law and the Preemptive Use of Military Force, 26(2) The Washington Quarterly 89 (2003).

4. Arimatsu L. The Law of State Responsibility in Relation to Border Crossings: An Ignored Legal Paradigm, 89 International Law Studies (U.S. Naval War College) 21 (2013).

5. Bengio O. The Kurds of Iraq: Building a State within a State (Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2012).

6. Bethlehem D. Principles Relevant to the Scope of a State’s Right of Self-Defence against an Imminent or Actual Armed Attack by Non-State Actors, 106 The American Journal of International Law 1 (2012).

7. Delibasis D. The Right to National Self-Defence: In Information Warfare Operations (Edmunds: Arena Books, 2007).

8. International Crisis Group, Turkey and the PKK: Saving the Peace Process, Europe Report No. 234 (Brussels, 2014).

9. Keskin F. Turkey’s Trans-Border Operations in Northern Iraq: Before and after the Invasion of Iraq, 8 Research Journal of Internatıonal Studies 59 (2008).

10. Kittrich J. The Right of Individual Self-Defence in Public International Law (Berlin: Logos Verlag Berlin GmbH, 2008).

11. Kretzmer D. The Inherent Right to Self-Defence and Proportionality in Jus Ad Bellum, 24(1) The European Journal of International Law 235 (2013).

12. Limbert J. The Origins and Appearance of the Kurds in Pre-Islamic Iran, 1(2) Iranian Studies 41 (1968).

13. Mella J. Kurdistan and the Kurds: A Divided Homeland and a Nation without State (London: Western Kurdistan Association Publications, 2005).

14. Ocalan A. Democratic Confederalism (London: Transmedia Publishing Ltd., 2011).

15. Ocalan A. War and Peace in Kurdistan Perspectives for a Political Solution of the Kurdish Question (2nd ed., Cologne: International Initiative, 2009).

16. Shah N.A. Self-Defence, Anticipatory Self-Defence and Pre-Emption: International Law’s Response to Terrorism, 12(1) Journal of Conflict & Security Law 95 (2007).

17. Szabó K.T. Anticipatory Action in Self-Defence: Essence and Limits under International Law (Hague: T.M.C. Asser Press, 2011).

18. Uzun A. “Living Freedom”: The Evolution of the Kurdish Conflict in Turkey and the Efforts to Resolve It (Berlin: Berghof Foundation, 2014).

19. Van Den Hole L. Anticipatory Self-Defence under International Law, 19(1) American University International Law Review 69 (2003).

20. Wilmshurst E. Principles of International Law on the Use of Force by States in SelfDefence (London: Chatham House, 2005).


Supplementary files

For citation: Khdir R. The Right to Self-Defence in International Law as a Justification for Crossing Borders: The Turkey-PKK Case within the Borders of Iraq. Russian Law Journal. 2016;4(4):62-80. https://doi.org/10.17589/2309-8678-2016-4-4-62-80

Views: 1038

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN 2309-8678 (Print)
ISSN 2312-3605 (Online)