SOVEREIGNTY AND HUMAN RIGHTS: COMPLEMENTARY OR ANTAGONISTIC?
Main Article Content
Abstract
The sovereignty today still constitutes a large part of the reasons for the limitations of the global human rights system, as countries strongly adhere to their sovereignty in the face of the global human rights movement, even if it means violating the rights of their citizens, oblivious to the fact that adherence to the global rules of human rights is essentially an affirmation of the principle of sovereignty. This is because countries have committed to the global rules of human rights by their own will, so the true universality of human rights is based on national action and therefore does not fundamentally conflict between international protection of human rights and the principle of sovereignty.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
References
FaisalaiyadJaafar,"The principle of sovereignty in public international law"Kufa Journal of Legal and Political Sciences,University of Kufa, Volume 01, Issue 14,2012, p. 324.
NawariAhlam,“The decline of national sovereignty in light of international transformations,” Journal of Politics and Law Notebooks, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, University of Ouargla, Issue 04, 2011,p. 28.
Talat Laji Al-Hadidi, Principles of International Law in Light of International Changes (Globalization), Dar Al-Hamid for Publishing and Distribution, 1st edition, Amman, 2012, pp. 94-95. Safwan Muhammad Ahmed and Naif Ahmed Al-Dahi, “Sovereignty in the Age of Globalization, a study Legal”, Tikrit University Journal of Humanities, Tikrit University, Volume 16, Issue 04, 2009, pp. 442-443.
Saad HaqqiTawfiq,Principles of international relations,1stedition,Dar Wael for Publishing and Distribution,Jordan,2000, p. 386.
Majed Omran,"Sovereignty under international protection of human rights",Damascus University Journal of Economic and Legal Sciences, Damascus university,Volume 27,n01,2011,p. 446. NawariAhlam,Opcit,p. 29.
Muhammad Younis Al-Sayegh,"The status of sovereignty under a world government -A comparative study"Al-Rafidain Law Journal,University of Mosul, Vol15,Issue 55, 2012, p. 23.
Saad HaqqiTawfiq,Opcit,p. 385.
Mustafa Salama Hussein,"International Reflections on Human Rights,” Egyptian Journal of International Law, Egyptian Society of International Law, No. 40, 1984., p. 192–193.
Ahmed Wafi, International Human Rights Mechanisms and the Principle of Sovereignty, Ph.D. Thesis, International Human Rights Law, Faculty of Law, University of Algiers 01, 2011, p. 99..
Mohamed Kaddour Boumediene,Human Rights between the National Authority and the International Authority, 1st edition, Dar Al-Raya for Publishing and Distribution, Amman 2010,p. 82.
Yahya Yassin Saud,Human Rights between State Sovereignty and International Protection, 1st edition, National Center for Legal Publications, Cairo, 2016, p. 123.
Saad HaqqiTawfiq,Opcit,p. 387.
Majed Omran,“Sovereignty under the International Protection of Human Rights,” Damascus University Journal of Economic and Legal Sciences, Damascus University, Volume 27, Issue 01, 2011,p. 465.
Saeed Al-Siddiqi,"Human rights and the limits of national sovereignty",Collective book: Sovereignty and Power,theaTranscending national and global borders,Opcit, p p103-104.
Saud Ahmed Rayhan,"The future of sovereignty in light of new international changes:A future analytical study",UniversityJournalaNabar for Human Sciences,University ofaNabar, issue01,2012,p. 308.
Jost Delbruck, “International protection of human rights and states autonomy”, Indiana law journal, Maurer school of law, Indiana university, Vol 57, N° 04, 1992, P 574.
Pierre-Henri Imbert. Les reserves aux traites multilateraux, 1 rediton. editions A pedone 1979, P 483.
Kheiri Ahmad Al-Kabbash,Criminal Protection of Human Rights, “A Comparative Study,” 1st edition, Dar Al-Jama’een, Alexandria, 2002, p.s73–74.
Mustafa Al-Filali“An Analytical View of Human Rights through Charters and Declarations of Organizations,” collective work: Human Rights, Global, Islamic, and Arab Perspectives, 1st edition, Center for Arab Unity Studies, Beirut, 2005.., sp. 26– 27.
Pierr Henri Imbert, «La France et les traites relatifs aux droits de Lhomme», in L'annuaire Français de droit international, Vol 26, 1980, P 39.
Ibid, p 42.
Muhammad Mohieddin,Summary of lectures on human rights, Dar Al-Khaldounia, Algeria, 2001/2012,P. 79, Ali Mazouz, Cultural Specificities and the Universality of Human Rights, Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Law and Commercial Sciences,University of Boumerdes,2005,p. 137.
Nicholas Doyle, “The ASEAN human rights declaration and the implication of recent ASEAN intiative in human rights institution building and standards-setting”, international and comparative law quaterly, British institute of international and comparative law, Vol 36, Part 1, 2014, P69.
GiserGvanvig, “asean, sovereignty and human rights”,www.jus.uio.no/.../asean-sovereignty-and-human-rights---gisle-kv,P08.
Mustafa Al-Filali,Opcit,p. 30. Radwan Ziadeh,The march of human rights in the Arab world,1st edition, Arab Cultural Center, Beirut, Lebanon, 2000ss206 –207.
Mohamed Kaddour Boumediene,Human rights between national authority and international authority,i1, Dar Al-Raya Publishing and Distribution, Amman 2010, p. 74.
Baya Abdul Qadir,The International Covenants on Human Rights between Commitment and Reservation, 1st edition, Dar Houma, Algeria, 2014. p. 74.
Muhammad Abbas Mohsen,"The constitutional organization of the ratification of international treaties, a comparative study",Islamic College Magazine,University of Najaf Al-Ashraf, No14, 2011,p. 327.
Muhammad Saeed Al-Daqqaq and Mustafa Salama Hussein,Contemporary International Law, University Press House, Alexandria, 2016,p. 92.
Emilie M.Hafner-Burton and LiyoteruTstsui, “Human rights in a globalizing world the paradox of empty promises”, American journal of sociology, University of Chicago, Vol 110, N° 5, 2005, P 1386.
Habib Hamdoni and HafizaShaqir, Human Rights of Women between International Recognition and Reservations of Arab States, 1st edition, Cairo Centre for Human Rights Studies, 2008, p. 94
Kargali Mustafa, Reservation under International Human Rights Law, Master ' s Note, International Human Rights Law, Faculty of Law and Commercial Sciences, University of Boumerdas, 2006, p. 108
Susan Marks, “Three regional human right treaties and their experience of reservation”,in:Human rights as general norms and a state’s right to opt out, reservations and objections to human rights conventions,1st edition,G P Gardner editions,UK,1997,P61
Yahya Yassin Saud,Opcit,pp260–261.