THE ENFORCEMENT OF ELECTRONIC ADMINISTRATIVE DECISION AND THE EXTENT OF ITS APPLICATION IN PALESTINE AND JORDAN
Main Article Content
Abstract
Electronic management means a set of administrative activities that depend on the internet at all levels of public administration. The transformation of the procedure from paper-based into electronic pillar has impacted the administrative decision. Therefore, the administrative decision has become issued by electronic procedures and relies on the electronic pillar based on paper or document. This led to the emergence of new legal terms, such as the electronic administrative decision. However, several legal questions have arisen about the legality of electronic administrative decisions and their legal effects. And what is the moment in which the electronic administrative decision is considered to have been issued and effective? This paper aims to demonstrate the legality of the application of the electronic administrative decision in Palestine and Jordan. To achieve the research objectives, a qualitative legal research approach has been adopted. The primary and secondary data have been both utilized in this research to help answer the research question. Findings show that the Palestinian and Jordanian legislation has not prevented the administration from expressing its will by using modern technological means; also, the legislator has not required the issuance of the decision to be written or verbally. The authors recommend activating the role of the Supreme Court of Justice. Besides, make some amendments to the Palestinian decision No. 15 of 2017 regarding electronic transactions and Jordanian law in the Electronic Transactions Law No. 15 of 2015 to keep pace with this development.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
References
Al Amaren, Emad Mohammad, et al. An introduction to the legal research method: To clear the blurred image on how students understand the method of the legal science research. International Journal of Multidisciplinary Sciences and Advanced Technology, 2020, 1.9: 50-55.
Adnan Amr, Administrative Judiciary and Cancellation Court, (Second Edition, Al Maaref Establishment, Alexandria, 2004), 55.
Alnsour, Jamal Ahmad. "Managing urban growth in the city of Amman, Jordan." Cities 50 (2016): 93-99.
Abdullah Ahmad Al-Khader, Legal System for the Electronic Government of the State of Kuwait, (Munsha't Almuarf, Alexandria, 2006), 40.
Abdel Fattah Bayoumi Hegazy, The Legal System for the Protection of Electronic Government, (Dar Alfikr Aljamieh, Alexandria, First Edition, 2003), 45.
Ammar Tariq Abdul Aziz, “Pillars of the Electronic Administrative Decision, Published Research,” Journal of Law for Legal Studies and Research 2, no. 1, (January 2011): 9-25.
Adnan Amr, Announcing Administrative Decisions Harmful to Individuals and Employees, (The Palestinian Independent Commission for Citizen Rights, Ramallah, 2001), 11.
Alaa Abdul-Razzaq Al-Salmi, Electronic Administration, (Second Edition, Dar Wayil Lilnashr, Amman, Jordan, 2009), 20.
Abdel Fattah Bayoumi Hegazy, Legal System for the Protection of E-Government, ((Dar Al-Fikr Aljamiah, Alexandria, 2003), 31.
Alshawabkeh, M. A., Yassine, C., & Ezzerouali, S. (2023). Constitutional Legitimacy of Measures Restricting Public Liberties: Procedures of confronting Corona Crisis as a Model. resmilitaris, 13(2), 3113-3125.
Brown, David. "Electronic government and public administration." International Review of Administrative Sciences 71, no. 2 (2005): 241-254.
Bashir Ali Baz, Role of Electronic Government in Administrative Decision Making and Electronic Voting, (Legal Books Dar, Arab Republic of Egypt, 2009), 16.
Razan Talal Sabbidine, "Increasing Principals’ Autonomy in Administrative Decisions in Lebanese Public Schools." (PhD diss., 2021): 15.
Nasser Abd Al-Halim Al-Salamat, “Enforcement of the Electronic Administrative Decision,” Journal of Sharia and Law Sciences Studies 40, no. 2 (January 2013): 1040.
Terry Hutchinson and Duncan Nigel. "Defining and describing what we do: Doctrinal legal research." Deakin L. Rev. 17 (2012): 83.
Nawaf Kanaan, Al Wajeez in Jordanian Administrative Law, (Dar Alafaq Almushariqat Lilnashri, 2012), 218.
Essam Al-Barzanji, “Discretionary Authority for Administration and Administrative Control,” (PhD Thesis, Cairo University, 2000), 210.
Hamdi Okasha, Mawsuea of Administrative Decisions in the State Council District, (Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2007), 55.
Muhammad Jamal Al-Zunaibat, Al-Wajeez in Administrative Law, (Dar Wayil Lilnashr, Cairo, 2003), 198.
Muhammad Hamada, Administrative Decisions and Supervision of the Administrative Judiciary, (Dar Al-Fikr Aljamiah, Cairo, 2004), 10.
Issam Muhammad Al-Buhaisi, “Modern Information Technology and its Impact on Administrative Decisions in Business Organizations” Journal of the Islamic University of Gaza 15, no. 1 (January 2006): 155-177.
Fouad Youssef Al-Jubouri, Sumaya Abbas Majeed Al-Rubaie, Amal Mahmoud Ali Al-Obaidi, “Crisis Management and Electronic Decision-Making” Journal of the Babylon University 19, no. 1 (January 2011): 5-20.
Muhammad Saeed Hussein Amin, Withdrawal of the Administrative Decision Between the Discretionary Authority and the Restricting Authority of the Administration, (Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2005), 12.
Musa Mustafa Shehadeh, Administrative Decision Preparation, An Applied Study on Police Administrative Decision, Sharjah Police General Command, (Research and Studies Centre, Sharjah, 1999), 15.
Sumaya Abdo Hodeid, “Specialization in Administrative Decision, a Comparative Study” (PhD Thesis, Faculty of Law, Cairo University, 2012), 5.
Muhammad Sulaiman Shabir, “Electronic Access to Administrative Decision: A Comparative Applied Study,” (PhD Thesis, Ain Shams University, 2015), 49.
Muhammad Anwar Hamadeh, Administrative Decisions and Judicial Oversight, (Dar Alfikr Aljamiei, Alexandria, 2004), 17.
Palestinian Local Authorities Law No. 1 of 1997, Article 20, which states that: “Immovable local property is registered in the name of the local authority, and these properties are not sold, exchanged, donated, mortgaged, or leased for a period of more than three years, without a decision from the council approved by the minister"
Iyad Muhammad Ata Sadah, “Authenticity of Electronic Documents in Evidence, A Comparative Study” (Master Thesis, An-Najah National University, Nablus, Palestine, 2009), 45.
Raed Muhammad Al-Adwan, “Enforcement of the Administrative Decision against Individuals” (A Comparative Study of Jordanian and Egyptian Law, Master Thesis, Middle East University, 2013), 10.
Ibrahim Al-Desouki Abu Al-Layl, “Legal Aspects of Interacting via Modern Communication Means” (Research Presented to the Conference on Law, Computers and the Internet, held at the College of Sharia and Law at the Emirates University, 2000) 10.
Daoud Abdel-Razek Al-Baz, E-Government and its Impact on the Legal System of the Public Utility and the Work of Its Employees, (Al Maaref Establishment, Alexandria, 2015), 50.
Muflih Awad Al-Qudah, Evidence in Civil and Commercial Articles, (Dar Al Thaqafa, Amman, second edition, 1994), 21.
Osama Ahmed El-Meligy, Use of Extracts of Modern Scientific Techniques and its Impact on the Rules of Civil Evidence, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2000), 79.
Ibrahim Al-Desouki Abu Al-Layl, “Electronic Signature and Its Authenticity in Evidence” (Research Presented within the works of the Law and Computer Conference, Yarmouk University, Jordan, 2004,) 6.
Hamdi Sulaiman Al-Qubeilat, “Signature as a Form in the Electronic Administrative Decision” Journal of Sharia and Law Sciences, University of Jordan 14, no.1 (January 2007): 68-80.
hosnia, a. o., & yassine, c. (2023). criminal cases related to cheques in the light of the omani litigation procedures facilitation law pursuant to royal decree no. 125/2020. russian law journal, 11(3).
Hamad, A. M., & binti Halim, R. (2021). The Judiciary in Islamic Law, Palestinian Legislation, and Guarantees of Its Independence. Samarah: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga dan Hukum Islam, 5(1), 1-22.
Taghreed Mostafa Gomaa, “Electronic Publishing in Egyptian Universities, Analytical Survey Study” (Master Thesis, Faculty of Arts, Cairo University, 2013) 12.
Novan Al-Aqeel Al-Ajarmah, “Enforcement of the Electronic Administrative Decision,” Journal of Studies of Sharia and Law Sciences 40, no. 1 (May 2013): 1024.
Sherif Kamel Shaheen, Electronic Information Sources in Libraries and Documentation Centers, (Al Dar Almisriua Al Lubnaniuh, Cairo, 2010), 55.
Sabah Muhammad Chloe, “E-Marketing for Free Access Online Journals” Al-Mansour Magazine in Iraq, March 8, 2012, https://www.muc.edu.iq.
Khaled Al-Zubaidi, “Theory of Certain Science in Jurisprudence and Administrative Justice with a Focus on the Supreme Court of Justice: A Comparative Study” Journal of Studies of Sharia and Law Sciences, University of Jordan 34, no. 1 (January 2007): 15.
Khaled Al-Zubaidi, “Theory of Certain Science in Jurisprudence and Administrative Justice with a Focus on the Supreme Court of Justice: A Comparative Study” 16.
Yassine, C. (2020). malicious lawsuit as a means of abusing the right to litigation in the code of civil and administrative procedures of algeria. Journal of college of Law for Legal and Political Sciences, 9, 198-225.
Ziad Khalif Al-Anzi, Conflict of Laws in Electronic Transactions, Doctor's Message, (Ain Shams University, 2008), 20.
Website of the Palestinian General Personnel Council, accessed November 23, 2020, http://www.diwan.ps/ar.
Ministry of Transport and Communications, accessed November 23, 2020, www.mot.gov.ps/site/596/Default.aspx.
Means of Knowing the Administrative Decision, (Supreme Court of Justice, Case No. 230/2004, dated July 15, 2005(
Means of Knowing the Administrative Decision, (Supreme Court of Justice, Case No. 20 of 2001, dated 6/17/2003)
Judgment of the Supreme Court of Justice, Palestine - Ramallah, in Administrative Case No. 274 of 2009, dated 5/24/2010. Al-Muqtafi Electronic Encyclopedia, muqtafi.birzeit.edu/ welcome.aspx.